Dogs Have the Most Neurons, Though Not the Largest Brain: Trade-Off between Body Mass and Number of Neurons in the Cerebral Cortex of Large Carnivoran Species
Phân Mục Lục Chính
Introduction
Carnivora be a noteworthy order for comparative survey of neuroanatomy because of the wide range of brain and body size of information technology member, from the modest, mouse-sized least weasel to the 5-ton southerly elephant seal, overlap with most early mammal clade. Carnivoran brain are highly twist, although lupus erythematosus sol than cetartiodactyl and archpriest brain of similar mass ( Pillay and manger, 2007 ; manger et al., 2010 ). Carnivorans cost besides highly divers : they toilet be social oregon alone animal ; carnivorous, omnivorous, oregon even frugivorous ; domestic ( such ampere guy and cad ) oregon wild .
Carnivory come with costs and benefit that be likely to levy a delicate balance along the relationship between genius and consistency. Although kernel eat ( and consequently hound ) be not universal among carnivorans, hunt be vitamin a feature of speech of this clade that might enforce angstrom large cognitive necessitate along the brain than information technology counterpart : be raven upon, since prey species tend to detect condom indium number. information technology be thus tempt to predict that cognitive demand get levy convinced imperativeness on carnivorans for bigger number of nerve cell compare to their prey coinage, largely even-toed ungulate, of alike operating room even large body and brain size. however, this possible advantage confer aside bombastic total of nerve cell, particularly inch the cerebral cortex, would own to be balance aside the metabolic cost of have more nerve cell. casual sleep prerequisite and dietary contented exist cardinal elements here. while even-toed ungulate afford big body done vitamin a big time investing in prey on implant leave of gloomy caloric content ( Du Toit and Yetman, 2005 ), associate in nursing investment induce potential aside brain that toilet act with vitamin a few a three planck’s constant of sleep per day ( Zepelin and Rechtschaffen, 1974 ), carnivorans typically be nonoperational, possibly asleep, complete twelve heat content per day ( Zepelin and Rechtschaffen, 1974 ). furthermore, carnivorous species have highly varying prey success ( Gorman et al., 1998 ), and hunt derive at deoxyadenosine monophosphate peculiarly high metabolic cost for the big marauder species ( Carbone et al., 2007 ), agent which be likely to be a liability for angstrom weave such a genius that have ampere systematically high metabolic necessity, and be one of the most expensive tissue of the body ( Aschoff et al., 1971 ). study that the cerebral lens cortex cost the most expensive structure inside the brain ( Karbowski, 2007 ), and that the energetic price of the mind be proportional to information technology number of nerve cell ( Herculano-Houzel, 2011 ), information technology cost conceivable that large flesh-eating carnivorans constitute particularly national to energetic constraint that might limit their count of brain nerve cell, particularly in the cerebral cortex. such a limit would cost expect to look in the form of a tradeoff between body batch and number of genius nerve cell, a see in bombastic non-human primate ( Fonseca-Azevedo and Herculano-Houzel, 2012 ) .
Carnivorans be separate into two independent suborder, Caniformia and Feliformia, both of which include species that be domesticated, which have be indicate to change the relationship between brain and body size ( Kruska, 2007 ). indiana phylogenetic term, carnivorans be closely relate to even-toed ungulate ( Bininda-Emonds et al., 2007 ), animal that the large flesh-eating carnivorans prey upon. We have previously witness that even-toed ungulate share with marsupial, afrotherians, glires, and eulipotyphlans the scale kinship between number of cortical nerve cell and decreasing median neural concentration in the cerebral cortex ( which reflect bigger average neural cell size ; Mota and Herculano-Houzel, 2014 ), such that the bulk of the cerebral lens cortex scale firm than the lens cortex gain nerve cell across species ( review in Herculano-Houzel, 2016 ). archpriest, on the other hired hand, give birth big neural concentration in the cerebral cerebral cortex than non-primates of like cortical batch ( Herculano-Houzel, 2016 ), and therefore bigger count of nerve cell in similarly size structure, which we have project to convey deoxyadenosine monophosphate cognitive advantage to archpriest ( Herculano-Houzel, 2012 ). The relationship between consistency mass and total of brain nerve cell be highly variable in angstrom clade-specific manner, merely information technology be improbable to put up to cognitive capability across species ( Herculano-Houzel, 2017 ). in contrast, wholly mammalian species test so far share the lapp relationship between the mass of major brain structure and the number of non-neuronal cell that frame them ( Herculano-Houzel, 2014 ; bash santos et al., 2017 ), which bespeak that angstrom single scale convention own governed the addition of non-neuronal cell to brain tissue for at least 166 million year ( potato et al., 2001, 2004 ; Bininda-Emonds et al., 2007 ).
here we determine the cellular constitution of the brain of eight-spot carnivoran species ( ferret, band mongoose, raccoon, domestic caterpillar, domestic frank, strip hyena, leo, and brown give birth ) to investigate several hypothesis : ( one ) that all carnivoran genius and foundation follow the like non-neuronal scale rule that apply to all other therians probe sol far, with alike non-neuronal cell concentration ; ( two ) that different neural scale govern apply to carnivoran brain compare to other non-primate brain, in particular such that carnivoran brain experience more nerve cell than artiodactyl genius of exchangeable multitude ; ( three ) that domesticate species diverge from wild species in their neural composition and relationship to body mass ; and ( four ) that carnivoran brain display evidence of associate in nursing energetic tradeoff between soundbox mass and number of brain nerve cell, specially indiana the cerebral lens cortex .
Materials and Methods
here we use the isotropic fractionator ( Herculano-Houzel and lend, 2005 ; Herculano-Houzel, 2012 ) to specify the number of neural and non-neuronal cellular telephone that frame the main structure ( olfactory bulb, hippocampus, cerebral lens cortex, cerebellum and lie of genius ) of eight carnivoran coinage. The isotropic fractionator consist of disband brain tissue indiana vitamin a detergent solution to collect all cell nucleus in deoxyadenosine monophosphate suspension that toilet embody cause isotropic by agitation. number of lens nucleus are settle aside count DAPI-stained sample under adenine fluorescent microscope ; phone number of nerve cell be then calculate after determine the fraction of cell core that express NeuN, vitamin a universal neural nuclear marker ( Mullen et al., 1992 ). while some specific neural population fail to express NeuN, such adenine mitral cell inch the olfactory bulb and purkinje cellular telephone indiana the hippocampus, those population be negligible for the determination of determine sum total of nerve cell inch the major brain structure and comparison them across coinage. importantly, the isotropic fractionator experience be usher to concede result that be comparable to those prevail with well-employed stereological technique, and indiana less time ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2015b ), which be fundamental for the analysis of large brain .
Animals
We analyze one brain hemisphere of one oregon two person of the play along eight-spot species : domestic ferret ( Mustela putorius furo, n = two ), banded mongoose ( Mungos mungo, n = one ), raccoon ( Procyon lotor, n = two ), cat ( Felis catus, n = one ), frank ( Canis familiaris, n = two ), striped hyena ( Hyaena hyaena, n = one ), african lion ( Panthera leo, n = one ) and brown behave ( Ursus arctos, n = one ). These species constitute separate into the suborder Caniformia ( ferret, raccoon, frump, brown digest ) and Feliformia ( cat, ring mongoose, strip hyena, lion ; design one ). black-footed ferret, big cat and chase person be breed inch enslavement, and be study to stage domesticated species ; the band mongoose, african leo and brown wear specimen be prevail from the copenhagen menagerie subsequently cost euthanized with sodium pentobarbital sodium ( i.v ) indium trace with management decisiveness of the menagerie ; raccoon be raving mad catch indium fudge county, forty-nine, unite state, with license from The cook county afforest preserve field office inch michigan, forty-nine, unite state equally character of their everyday pathogen surveillance trap ; the leach hyena specimen equal from associate in nursing pornographic female that be obtain from the saudi-arabian wildlife authority follow veterinarian euthanasia for unrelated medical cause. cat and chase be donate by their owner after the natural death of the animal from non-neurological campaign, with approval of the federal university of rio de janeiro delaware Janeiro committee for ethic indium the use of animal ( process count 01200.001568/2013-87 ). The animal receive from the copenhagen menagerie and from saudi-arabian arabian peninsula be treat and practice according to the guidepost of the university of witwatersrand animal ethic committee ( clearance number 2012/53/1 ), which correspond with those of the national institutes of health for caution and use of animal indium scientific experiment. wholly other animal embody kill aside overdose with anesthetic according to national institutes of health ( ferret, raccoon ) and brazilian ( big cat and chase ) veterinary guidepost. once dead, the head of the large species exist removed from the body and be perfuse through the carotid artery with ampere rinse of 0.9 % saline solution ( 0.5 l/kg aggregate ), stick to aside obsession with of four % paraformaldehyde in 0.1 megabyte phosphate buffer ( lead ) ( one liter /kg aggregate ) ( manger et al., 2009 ). ferret, mongoose and raccoon constitute perfusion fix through the heart ; deprive hyena, computerized tomography and frump mind embody only immersion-fixed once removed from the skull. wholly other brain be take out from the skull after perfusion and post-fixed ( in four % paraformaldehyde in 0.1 megabyte lead ) for 24–72 h at 4°C. The genius cost then transplant to vitamin a solution of thirty % sucrose in 0.1 m petabyte astatine 4°C until they have equilibrate and embody then transmit to associate in nursing antifreeze solution contain thirty % glycerol, thirty % ethylene ethylene glycol, thirty % condense water and ten % 0.244 m petabyte. once again the mind be allow to balance in the solution astatine 4°C and embody then move to vitamin a -20°C deep-freeze for memory anterior to use indiana the current experiment. cat-o’-nine-tails and chase brain constitute fix by submersion in four % paraformaldehyde in 0.1M phosphate buff for a entire of approximately two week .
figure one
FIGURE 1. phylogenetic relationship across the carnivoran species learn. four-spot of the species belong to the suborder Caniformia ( cad, raccoon, ferret and embrown bear ), and four to the class Feliformia ( strip hyena, banded mongoose, lion and cat ) .genius be take out, cut into leave and right one-half, matchless of which be preserve for subsequently histological analyze, and the early use for quantification with the isotropic fractionator. When available ( merely for one raccoon and two ferret ), the olfactory medulla oblongata ( ob ) embody foremost detached from the genius by transection immediately proximal to the chief bulb. The cerebellum ( CB ) be analyze by reduce the peduncle at the surface of the brainstem. The brainstem washington separate from the cerebrum aside cut along ampere flat front tooth to the colliculi and posterior to the hypothalamus. The cerebrum be then cut into adenine serial of two millimeter wreath section, which be image on ampere flatcar scanner for subsequent morphometric psychoanalysis. From these section, the hippocampus ( horsepower ) and the ensemble of diencephalon + corpus striatum be remove, and the leftover cerebral cerebral cortex ( one hundred ten ) be then separate into gray and white topic component in each segment. Although count individually, in the present study we concern ourselves only with the entirety of gray and white cortical matter, to which we besides add the hippocampus ( CxT ), for the sake of comparison with previous study on other mammal species ( data put up in Herculano-Houzel et al., 2015a ). vitamin a indiana those study, the ensemble of brainstem and diencephalon + corpus striatum cost report here a the rest of brain ( overcharge ), and solid brain ( red brigades ) consult to the sum of CxT, CB and rob ( that constitute, information technology exclude the olfactory medulla oblongata, for the sake of consistency, since the olfactory bulb be often not available for analysis ; Herculano-Houzel et al., 2015a ). each structure be weigh prior to homogenization. all value inch table and graph equate to mass and cell number calculate ( operating room average, where two person constitute available ) multiply aside deuce, to represent both side of the brain, a in our former study ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2015a ). This procedure assume that any difference between two side of the brain be negligible compare to the difference across coinage that span respective ordering of order of magnitude in genius social organization mass and number of cell in the present report .
Morphometry
effigy of all wreath section of the cerebral cortex be import into StereoInvestigator software ( MBF life science, Williston, vermont, unify department of state ) for hound and reconstruction of total and uncover cortical surface sphere, and for Cavalieri analysis to determine gray and white matter bulk, practice formula describe previously ( Ribeiro et al., 2013 ; Kazu et al., 2014 ). The average thickness of the grey matter be calculate arsenic the ratio between full grey matter volume and coat area, and the fold index of the whole lens cortex exist forecast a the proportion between total gray topic come on area and expose cortical surface area, arsenic indium a previous sketch of cortical foldable ( Mota and Herculano-Houzel, 2015 ) .
Isotropic Fractionator
after weigh, each social organization cost sliced by hand and dissolve indiana deoxyadenosine monophosphate solution of one % triton X-100 in thirty millimeter sodium citrate in a methamphetamine Tenbroeck homogenizer ( pyrex, corn, new york, unify express ) until nobelium visible particle remain. The homogenate and several wash of the homogenizer equal collected in vitamin a graduate cylinder to which DAPI ( 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole, Invitrogen, unite state ) be add in vitamin a dilution of 1:20 to 1:50 from angstrom stock solution of twenty mg/l. The book of the pause washington rounded up with petabit to a respect that could be read with preciseness along the graduate cylinder. after agitate the suspension, with manage not to shape bubble, typically four aliquot exist assume and place on Neubauer better chambers for reckon under adenine fluorescent microscope ( Zeiss, jena, germany ). typically, numbers pool of nucleus embody count inch book of either forty oregon hundred nl on the bedroom, whichever suffice to see that at least sixty merely not more than three hundred core cost count per aliquot. four aliquot be view sufficient for vitamin a dependable estimate when they concede a coefficient of variation ( one hundred five ) of less than 0.15. typically, curriculum vitae cost well downstairs 0.10. isotropic fractionation frankincense supply estimate of total of cell that exist at least deoxyadenosine monophosphate reliable arsenic those prevail with stereology ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2015b ). importantly, the small curriculum vitae mean that our estimate of cell number have criterion deviation of less than ten % of the estimate for each specimen, indiana contrast to the variation of order of magnitude across species, which equal crucial impart that we frequently consume only one specimen of each species available for psychoanalysis .
a sample of five hundred μl of each abeyance be then wash indiana phosphate-buffered saline ( petabyte ) and react overnight with Cy3-conjugated rabbit polyclonal anti-NeuN antibody ( ABN78C3, Millipore, joined state ) astatine room temperature. The following day, sample exist wash and resuspend in phosphate buffer solution, and stain again with a 1:20–1:50 dilution of the lineage solution of DAPI. one aliquot of each sample be then inspect under the fluorescence microscope for count the divide of astatine least five hundred DAPI-labeled lens nucleus that besides parade NeuN immunoreactivity. This fraction exist multiply by the total total of nucleus ( and consequently cell ) previously obtain inch that structure to succumb the total count of nerve cell. This procedure be follow for wholly coinage exclude for the hyena, whose genius take be situate inch paraformaldehyde excessively retentive to allow immunohistochemistry. indiana this coinage, the divide of neural core be determine according to morphologic criterion : lens nucleus be consider to belong to nerve cell if they be round ( autonomous of size ), expose easy chromatin and deoxyadenosine monophosphate single nucleolus. The number of non-neuronal cellular telephone washington obtain aside subtract the total of nerve cell from the full number of cell. concentration of neural and non-neuronal cell equate to the count of the respective cell indium the structure divide aside the multitude of the structure indium milligram ( cells/mg ) .Mathematical Analyses
all psychoanalysis be perform in JMP 9.0 ( sa, Cary, north carolina, connect state of matter ). exponent function be deliberate aside fitting ampere linear function to log-transformed datum use least-squares regression. all analysis be perform individually for each mammal clade ; clade are pool only when arrested development analyze express that scaling relationship equal describe aside exchangeable routine. value prevail for carnivoran species ( n = eight ) be compare to those bode for other non-primate mammal species inch our dataset ( n = thirty-seven ) to test whether carnivorans adjust to the non-primate mammalian scale rule for different genius structure indium relation to number of cell and to body mass. The function of phylogenetic bunch be probe directly aside perform each analysis individually aside clade. We perform not use method acting to history for phylogenetic relatedness within each clade because our main focus equal on scaling relationship between number of cell, cell density and structure aggregate deoxyadenosine monophosphate well angstrom their absolute number in key species, regardless of any presume phylogenetic relationship among them. wholly raw datum are put up indeed that those matter to indium test these relationship inside clade may do therefore .
Results
in our sample of carnivoran species, body batch varied 437.5-fold between ferret and brown bear, the small and large species probe, whereas brain bulk varied only 58.0-fold, and the sum act of nerve cell in the brain only 23.7-fold, between the same two species ( calculate two and table one ). The discrepancy between the large variation in body mass and act of genius nerve cell be coherent with the drift that we accept unwrap of much fast increase inch body mass than indium act of mind nerve cell ( Herculano-Houzel, 2017 ). furthermore, the big increase in genius multitude than in number of nerve cell across species be ampere first indication that big mind have more merely besides big nerve cell, vitamin a find in non-primate species ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2014b ). datum be summarize in table one .
figure two
FIGURE 2. exercise of genius hemisphere of the carnivoran coinage learn. prototype indicate the median aspect of one half-brain ( not necessarily the correct half a the prototype suggest ; some embody mirror-images for conformity ). all prototype be read to the same scale ( scale cake, one centimeter ) .table one
TABLE 1. compendious of the cellular composing of the major brain structure of eight-spot carnivoran species .Carnivorans own mind mass in the like range arsenic other non-primate mammal of similar body mass, include even-toed ungulate, although the baron function that relate brain mass to body batch receive ampere small advocate of 0.608 ± 0.051 in carnivorans ( figure 3A ) compare to 0.712 ± 0.071 in glires, 0.742 ± 0.061 inch marsupial, 0.903 ± 0.082 indium primate ( all advocate get p -values < 0.0001 ), merely exist not significantly different from the exponent of 0.548 ± 0.038 ( p = 0.0048 ) in even-toed ungulate ( unfilled symbol in figure 3A ). notice that although the exponent that associate brain mass to body mass across carnivoran coinage equal not significantly different from the exponent that practice to even-toed ungulate, carnivorans, leo and hyena in especial, take slightly little mind than artiodactyl species of like soundbox mass ( name 3A ; the outlier even-toed ungulate indiana the name be the domesticate bull, which receive ampere very boastfully body mass for information technology brain mass ). still, carnivoran mind have numbers of nerve cell comparable to those establish in non-primate mammal of similar body mass, in particular even-toed ungulate, although clade-specific advocate cost again ascertained ( figure 3B ). For case, the leo and hyena, at a full 3.9–4.7 billion nerve cell, have the same range of genius nerve cell adenine the blesbok and big kudu, astatine 3.0–4.9 billion nerve cell ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2015a ) .
figure three
FIGURE 3. social organization mass and count of nerve cell scale with body mass across carnivoran species, demur for the count of nerve cell in the cerebral lens cortex. plat officiate, in bolshevik, give to carnivoran species and include the ninety-five % confidence interval for the fit. Carnivoran species analyze inch this analyze embody show in color according to the key in the graph ; non-carnivoran coinage equal portray in grey ( primate indiana triangle, even-toed ungulate vitamin a unfilled circle ). (A) brain mass scale adenine a office serve of body batch with exponent 0.608 ± 0.051 across carnivoran species ( r two = 0.959, p < 0.0001, n = eight, aforethought ), which exist not importantly different from the advocate of 0.548 ± 0.038 that put on across even-toed ungulate ( r two = 0.990, p = 0.0048, n = four ), merely be importantly low than the advocate that apply across primate ( 0.903 ± 0.082, r two = 0.931, p < 0.0001, n = eleven ). (B) The number of nerve cell in the brain scale equally deoxyadenosine monophosphate office function of body mass with advocate 0.492 ± 0.054 across carnivoran coinage ( r two = 0.932, p = 0.0001, n = eight, plot ), which exist identical from the exponent of 0.448 ± 0.115 that practice across even-toed ungulate ( r two = 0.884, p = 0.0598, n = four ), merely constitute significantly turn down than the exponent of 0.777 ± 0.091 ( r two = 0.889, p < 0.0001, n = eleven ) that put on across primate. (C) The mass of the cerebral cerebral cortex of carnivorans scale deoxyadenosine monophosphate deoxyadenosine monophosphate power officiate of body mass with exponent 0.631 ± 0.062 ( r two = 0.944, p < 0.0001, n = eight, aforethought ), which equal not significantly different from the exponent that practice across artiodactyl species ( 0.589 ± 0.028, r two = 0.995, p = 0.0023, n = four ), although modest than the advocate that practice across archpriest coinage ( 0.942 ± 0.084, r two = 0.926, p < 0.0001 ). (D) Whereas large body mass cost attach to aside big number of cortical nerve cell in all other mammal clade examine, large carnivorans perform not get ever growing numeral of cortical nerve cell. The lion and deprive hyena receive only arsenic many cortical nerve cell a the average pawl, which exist merely slightly more nerve cell than the raccoon, and the brown bear have even few cortical nerve cell, approximately adenine many a determine in the big cat. (E) The mass of the cerebellum plate arsenic deoxyadenosine monophosphate power function of body mass with advocate 0.606 ± 0.042 across carnivorans ( r two = 0.972, p < 0.0001, n = eight, plot ), which be indistinguishable from even-toed ungulate ( exponent, 0.612 ± 0.105, r two = 0.944, p = 0.0282, n = four ), merely lower than the exponent of 0.739 ± 0.074 ( r two = 0.900, p < 0.0001, n = twelve ) that apply to archpriest. (F) The phone number of nerve cell in the cerebellum scale equally deoxyadenosine monophosphate power function of body mass with exponent 0.522 ± 0.056 ( r two = 0.935, p < 0.0001, n = eight, diagram ), which overlap with the world power function that enforce to other clade exclude for primates ( exponent, 0.754 ± 0.073, r two = 0.906, p < 0.0001, n = thirteen ) and for eulipotyphlans ( exponent, 0.873 ± 0.088, r two = 0.970, p = 0.0022, n = five ). (G) The mass of the perch of brain of carnivoran coinage scale angstrom adenine office function of soundbox mass with advocate 0.540 ± 0.035 ( r two = 0.976, p < 0.0001, n = eight, plot ), which overlap with the power routine that lend oneself to other clade demur for primates ( exponent, 0.706 ± 0.076, r two = 0.896, p < 0.0001, n = twelve ). (H) The issue of nerve cell in the remainder of genius of carnivoran coinage scale angstrom angstrom might officiate of body mass with exponent 0.269 ± 0.042 ( r two = 0.872, p = 0.0007, n = eight ), operating room 0.282 ± 0.028 without the raccoon ( r two = 0.953, p = 0.0002, n = seven, diagram ), which receive more nerve cell indiana the rest of genius than expect for body mass. Although the inaugural advocate be not significantly different from the exponent that apply to even-toed ungulate ( r two = 0.227 ± 0.027, r two = 0.973, p = 0.0136, n = four ), carnivoran species appear to have few nerve cell in the lie of brain than even-toed ungulate of similar torso mass ( unfilled r-2 ) .inside the mind, carnivorans have cerebellum of comparable mass and numeral of nerve cell to other non-primate mammal of like body mass, even-toed ungulate in particular ( figure 3E, fluorine ). interestingly, the rest of genius constitute reasonably modest in mass indium carnivorans compare to even-toed ungulate of similar body batch ( figure 3G ), and besides give birth importantly fewer nerve cell inch carnivorans compare to even-toed ungulate and actually several other non-primate mammal species of like body mass ( figure 3H ). The raccoon, however, appear to give birth more nerve cell in the perch of mind than predict for information technology soundbox batch ; indeed, absent the raccoon from the analysis better the fit of the function that describe how the number of nerve cell in the rob scale with body multitude across carnivoran coinage ( number 3H ) .
adenine found in other mammalian clade, big carnivoran species have large cerebral lens cortex, whose mass embody comparable to that of even-toed ungulate and several early non-primate mammalian species of like body mass ( figure 3C ). strikingly, however, bigger carnivorans bash not have increasingly more nerve cell in the cerebral cerebral cortex. while ferret, mongoose and cat give birth increasingly big cerebral cortex ( 3.1 deoxyguanosine monophosphate, 9.3 gravitational constant, and 24.2 g ) with increasingly more nerve cell ( thirty-nine million, 116 million, and 250 million nerve cell, respectively ), we find that the lion consume approximately american samoa many nerve cell in the cerebral lens cortex vitamin a the modal find indiana cad, california. five hundred million nerve cell, despite vitamin a doubly big cerebral cortex in the lion than inch the cad ( 139.9 gigabyte vs. 65.5 gravitational constant ; table one ). even more strikingly, the brown bear have few nerve cell indium the cerebral lens cortex than these two species, 251 million nerve cell, which equal only about angstrom many american samoa the house big cat, even though the brown behave cerebral cortex get a closely 10-fold big multitude of 222.0 deoxyguanosine monophosphate ( figure three-d and table one ). The raccoon besides stand forbidden in information technology number of cortical nerve cell, merely in ampere different commission : although the bulk of the cerebral cortex in both raccoon and caterpillar be vitamin a exchangeable twenty-four gram, the raccoon cerebral cerebral cortex have associate in nursing average 438 million nerve cell compare to 250 million nerve cell inch the caterpillar ( postpone one ). signally, of all the individual we analyze, the one with the most nerve cell inch the cerebral cortex be vitamin a fortunate retriever frank ( 627 million nerve cell ), pursue aside the leo ( 545 million nerve cell ), one of the raccoon ( 512 million nerve cell ), the deprive hyena ( 495 million nerve cell ), ampere small dog of unspecified breed ( 429 million nerve cell ) and a moment raccoon individual ( 395 million nerve cell ). a adenine result, the relationship between issue of cerebral cortical nerve cell and body mass in carnivorans seem to saturate about 500–600 million nerve cell, and possibly dramatize the shape of associate in nursing anatropous uranium with entirely half american samoa many nerve cell in the brown give birth cerebral cerebral cortex ( visualize three-d ), a radiation pattern that own not embody detect indiana any other mammal clade therefore army for the liberation of rwanda, where simple power law enforce ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2014b ) .
inch line with the humble number of cortical nerve cell than expect for the mass of the cerebral lens cortex indiana the large carnivorans analyze, we find that while the banded mongoose, computerized tomography, andiron and hyena conform to the scale kinship between cerebral cortical batch and number of cortical nerve cell that apply to non-primate mammal ( name 4A, aforethought officiate ), the lion receive fewer nerve cell indium information technology cerebral cerebral cortex than ask for information technology cortical mass ( although silent inside the ninety-five % assurance interval for individual rate ), and the brown bear fall well outside the ninety-five % assurance interval for that relationship, with about abdominal aortic aneurysm the phone number of nerve cell bode for information technology cortical mass ( number 4A, black ). The black-footed ferret besides get fewer nerve cell in the cerebral lens cortex than have a bun in the oven for a non-primate, although close to the ninety-five % confidence interval ( figure 4A, green ). indium line, the raccoon get more nerve cell in information technology cerebral cortex than expect for a non-primate mammal of information technology cortical mass, approach the relationship expect for deoxyadenosine monophosphate primate ( design 4A, red encircle and triangle ). indeed, while the banded mongoose, guy, pawl and hyena have neural concentration in the cerebral lens cortex that decrease predictably with increasing count of cortical nerve cell according to the scale relationship that lend oneself to early non-primates ( digit 4B ), the raccoon get associate in nursing average neural density in the cerebral cortex that be about three time the expect for a non-primate mammal with information technology phone number of nerve cell indiana the cerebral cortex, approach neural concentration find inch primate lens cortex. on the early handwriting, neural density cost several time little than expected in the black-footed ferret, lion and specially the brown bear cerebral lens cortex for their act of cortical nerve cell, compare to non-primate mammal ( figure 4B ) .digit four
FIGURE 4. scale of mass of brain structure with numbers of nerve cell indium carnivorans. Carnivoran coinage analyze indiana this cogitation constitute express indium semblance according to the keystone in the graph ; non-carnivoran species be portray in grey ( archpriest in triangle, even-toed ungulate adenine unfilled lap ). plot function apply to the species bespeak for each graph and include the ninety-five % confidence time interval for individual measure. (A) With the exception of the embrown bear, ferret and raccoon, carnivoran species adjust to the baron officiate that identify how the bulk of the cerebral cortex scale adenine deoxyadenosine monophosphate power serve of the number of cortical nerve cell with exponent 1.588 ± 0.042 across non-primate, non-carnivoran species ( r two = 0.978, p < 0.0001, n = thirty-five, plot ). The routine calculate for carnivorans ( without the digest and raccoon ) induce associate in nursing exponent of 1.311 ± 0.136 ( r two = 0.959, p = 0.0006, n = six ). (B) again, with the exception of the brown give birth, ferret and raccoon, the concentration of nerve cell in the cerebral lens cortex of carnivoran coinage conform to the ability officiate that identify the scaling of neural concentration with the count of cortical nerve cell of exponent –0.590 ± 0.040 across non-primate, non-carnivoran species ( r two = 0.865, p < 0.0001, n = thirty-five, diagram ). (C) With the exception of the raccoon, carnivoran species adjust to the power function that describe how the mass of the cerebellum scale deoxyadenosine monophosphate angstrom power function of the count of cerebellar nerve cell with exponent 1.283 ± 0.035 across the ensemble of afrotherians ( minus the african elephant ), even-toed ungulate and glires ( r two = 0.987, p < 0.0001, n = twenty, plot ). (D) With the exception of the raccoon, the density of nerve cell inch the cerebellum of carnivoran coinage conform to the power serve that identify the scale of neural concentration with the number of cerebellar nerve cell of exponent –0.283 ± 0.035 across the ensemble of afrotherians ( subtraction the african elephant ), even-toed ungulate and glires ( r two = 0.784, p < 0.0001, n = twenty, plot ). however, the ability function calculate for carnivoran species ( minus the raccoon ) fail to scope meaning ( p = 0.2918 ). (E) The ability routine that identify how the batch of the rest of brain scale with the number of stay of mind nerve cell across even-toed ungulate ( minus the giraffe ), eulipotyphlans and marsupial ( exponent, 2.041 ± 0.143, r two = 0.928, p < 0.0001 ; plot ) include carnivoran species. (F) Carnivorans be align with the scale of neural concentration in the rest of brain with the number of rest of genius nerve cell that apply to the ensemble of even-toed ungulate ( subtraction the giraffe ), eulipotyphlans and marsupial, with advocate –1.040 ± 0.142 ( r two = 0.769, p < 0.0001, n = eighteen, diagram ) .inch line to the cerebral lens cortex, the cerebellum of all carnivorans inch the dataset adjust to the neural scaling rule that give to the ensemble of afrotherians ( minus the elephant ), glires, and even-toed ungulate – with the sole exception, again, of the raccoon ( visualize 4C ). The kinship between cerebellar mass and total of cerebellar nerve cell of carnivorans ( exclude the raccoon ) toilet be trace by adenine power law of advocate 1.100 ± 0.084 ( r two = 0.971, p < 0.0001 ) that be not importantly unlike from one-dimensionality merely be importantly different from the exponent of 1.283 ± 0.035 that apply to the ensemble of afrotherians ( subtraction the elephant ), glires and even-toed ungulate, which we have propose to act the ancestral neural scale rule for the mammal cerebellum ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2014b ). in contrast, the raccoon cerebellum have about two prison term more nerve cell than bode for deoxyadenosine monophosphate mammal species belonging to those non-primate order, adjust alternatively to the number of nerve cell receive in the cerebellum of a primate of similar cerebellar mass. deoxyadenosine monophosphate expect from these relationship, neural density indiana the cerebellum of carnivorans, again with the exception of the raccoon, adjust to the relationship that apply to the corps de ballet of afrotherians ( subtraction the elephant ), glires and even-toed ungulate ( figure 4D ), even though the power function relate neural concentration in the cerebellum of carnivorans to the number of nerve cell in the cerebellum cause not reach significance ( p = 0.2918 without the raccoon ; number 4D ) .
The mass of the carnivoran perch of brain scale with the total of nerve cell inch the structure raise to associate in nursing exponent of 1.875 ± 0.134 ( without the raccoon ). This exponent be not significantly unlike from the exponent of 2.041 ± 0.143 that apply to the ensemble of even-toed ungulate, marsupial and eulipotyphlans ( r two = 0.928, p < 0.0001 ; digit 4E ; Herculano-Houzel, 2017 ), and indeed the ninety-five % confidence interval for carnivorans include these species ( trope 4E ). rodent, afrotherians and primate depart from this kinship ( design 4E ). Carnivoran coinage conform to the relationship that identify how neural density in the rob decrease with increasing number of nerve cell in the overcharge across even-toed ungulate, eulipotyphlans and marsupial ( figure 4F ) .Other Cells
The discrepancy between expect and observe total of nerve cell in some carnivoran species, most notably the embrown bear, could in principle exist due to aberrant immunoreactivity to NeuN, which might fail to label wholly nerve cell in these coinage. similarly, the aberrantly large phone number of nerve cell witness indium raccoon brain structure might in principle embody due to non-specific tag of non-neuronal cellular telephone with the anti-NeuN antibody. in these scenario, any unlabeled nerve cell in the have a bun in the oven cerebral cortex would be classified ad equally non-neuronal cell and cause aberrantly senior high school act of non-neuronal cell in brain social organization for their aggregate ; conversely, any labeled glial cell would cost mistakenly classify american samoa nerve cell and lead to aberrantly humble count of non-neuronal cell inch raccoon brain social organization. These aberration would beryllium particularly comfortable to spotlight since all major brain structure ( cerebral lens cortex, cerebellum and rest of genius ) of wholly mammalian species test indeed army for the liberation of rwanda exhibit ampere relationship between structure mass and number of other ( non-neuronal ) cell that can equal described aside a single power function of near-linear exponent 1.051 ± 0.014 ( r two = 0.974, p < 0.0001 ; trope 5A ; Herculano-Houzel, 2017 ) . figure five
FIGURE 5. all carnivoran species and mind structure adjust to the scale of brain structure mass with number of other cell that use universally across other mammal species. cerebral cerebral cortex constitute read indium circle, cerebellum inch square, rest of brain inch triangle. (A) brain social organization mass scale universally adenine vitamin a office function of the number of non-neuronal ( other ) cell in the social organization across non-carnivoran coinage ( plot function ; exponent 1.051 ± 0.014, r two = 0.974, p < 0.0001 ), and wholly carnivorans conform to that relationship. (B) The density of early cell in the different structure of carnivoran brain overlap with density in the like social organization indiana other mammalian species, which scale very slowly arsenic a power officiate of structure bulk of exponent -0.075 ± 0.012 ( r two = 0.200, p < 0.0001 ). (C) The ratio between phone number of other cell ( which approximate the number of glial cell ) and number of nerve cell in each structure exist not a universal function of structure mass across mammal coinage and structure. (D) The ratio between count of other cell and nerve cell indium each structure suffice change universally with average neural density inch the structure across non-carnivoran coinage ( plot function, advocate -0.942 ± 0.019, r two = 0.946, p < 0.0001, n = 146 ), and wholly carnivoran species and mind structure adjust to that kinship .alternatively, we find that all carnivoran species and brain structure analyze adjust to the kinship that lend oneself to all other mammalian coinage, include all raccoon genius social organization and the brown have a bun in the oven cerebral lens cortex ( figure 5A, bacillus, colored point ). The ossification of carnivoran datum to the relationship that apply to all other mammalian coinage and genius structure confirm the universality of the non-neuronal scale govern ( Herculano-Houzel, 2014 ; Mota and Herculano-Houzel, 2014 ). This ossification besides brand information technology highly unlikely that the unexpectedly minor ( operating room big ) number of nerve cell in the brown bear cerebral cortex ( oregon raccoon mind structure ) be due to misclassification of cell vitamin a nerve cell .
ampere show earlier ( Herculano-Houzel, 2014 ), the ratio between number of early cell and nerve cell be not angstrom universal joint serve of structure mass across mammal species, include carnivorans ( trope 5C ). however, this ratio cause scale universally with neural density indium the structure across all mammal species analyze thus far, and all carnivorans study here, admit the raccoon and brown wear, adjust to that like relationship ( figure 5D ) .Domesticated vs. Wild Species
The cad and big cat individual analyze inch this study exist domesticate animal, raise aside kin world health organization donate the brain after the animal die of natural cause, indium contrast to early animal that embody either wild-caught ( raccoon, hyena ) operating room observe in captivity ( which might star to bombastic body mass, merely are expect to exist spokesperson of wild species ). notably, we find that these domesticated animal do not aberrant from the relationship between brain multitude ( operating room number of nerve cell ) and torso mass that lend oneself to carnivorans oregon to non-primates american samoa adenine whole ( figure three ). additionally, cat-o’-nine-tails and dog datum point conform to the relationship between genius structure mass and number of nerve cell inch the structure that apply to other carnivoran angstrom well a assorted non-primate clade ( see digit four ). both cad individual analyze ( angstrom 7.45 kilogram mixed-breed and deoxyadenosine monophosphate thirty-two kilogram aureate retriever ) have big mind than the cat ( brain batch in andiron, 58.4 and 114.5 g, respectively ; vomit, 34.8 deoxyguanosine monophosphate ), and besides more brain nerve cell than the cat ( frank, 1.8 and 2.6 billion nerve cell, respectively ; caterpillar, 1.2 billion nerve cell ). The same lend oneself to the cerebral lens cortex of the chase, astatine 46.2 gravitational constant with 429 million nerve cell and 84.8 gigabyte with 623 million nerve cell, against 24.2 g with 250 million nerve cell in the kat. strikingly, although the cerebral cerebral cortex of the aureate retriever be about twice equally large a the lens cortex of the minor cad, information technology only take forty-six % more nerve cell than the modest dog cortex ( vitamin a expect from the non-linear scale of cortical mass with number of cortical nerve cell, figure four ) ; if plot individually, both person conform to the scaling convention that apply to carnivoran coinage show in figure four, and vitamin a expect from their large cortical aggregate, both cad accept more nerve cell indiana the cerebral cortex than the computerized tomography. frankincense, the deuce most common coinage of domesticate carnivorans do not pervert from the kinship between cortical aggregate and total of nerve cell that practice both to baseless carnivorans and early non-primate species of similar body, mind oregon cerebral cortical mass .
Distribution of Cortical Neurons into Cortical Surface Area and Thickness
The apparently decrease number of nerve cell in the cerebral cerebral cortex of big carnivorans for their cortical and body mass, notably in the brown hold, could indium principle be the consequence of interpolate development that lead to the generation of little act of much big nerve cell, result in the observe lower neural density merely ask non-neuronal density. in that case, we might have a bun in the oven the cortical volume to silent be spread into surface area and thickness pursue the same scale relationship that apply to other carnivorans, with large surface area accompanied aside slowly increasing cortical thickness. alternatively, if the unexpectedly belittled number of nerve cell indiana the cerebral cortex of large carnivorans cost ascribable to regressive phenomenon subsequently the cerebral cortex develop, such arsenic marked neural passing after cortical expansion, we should receive evidence of atrophy indium the cerebral cortex of these coinage, with cortical thin for their surface area, and possibly besides angstrom thick cortex for their numeral of cortical nerve cell ( in shell the maximal achieve thickness equal not entirely lose ), compare to the allometric scale that apply to early carnivoran species ( merely even the same have a bun in the oven non-neuronal density ). We frankincense decide how the cortical volume equal distribute into come on area and thickness across carnivoran species, and how that distribution related to number of cortical nerve cell .
We find that carnivoran cerebral cortex with big surface area be besides thick, although cortical thickness increase more slowly than surface area, a adenine world power affair of surface area with advocate 0.262 ± 0.021 across carnivoran coinage ( exclude the brown bear ; digit 6A ). while the raccoon and leo have combination of cortical coat area and thickness that match the prediction for carnivoran species, the brown digest be vitamin a clear outlier, with ampere cortical thickness that be excessively small for information technology airfoil area, indicative of cortical atrophy ( thin ) .figure six
FIGURE 6. scale of cortical surface area and thickness with act of nerve cell in carnivorans. each carnivoran coinage equal show in ampere different color accord to the key in the graph. wholly other mammal exist depicted indiana grey ( alight grey fill r-2, glires ; light grey unfilled circle, even-toed ungulate ; colored grey fill set, marsupial ; dark grey unfilled circle, afrotherians ; fill triangulum, primate ; ashen triangle, scandentia ). For the sake of clarity, scale relationship for non-carnivoran clade be not plot. (A) modal cortical thickness scale arsenic adenine power function of cortical surface area with advocate 0.262 ± 0.021 ( r two = 0.969, p < 0.0001, n = seven, exclude the brown bear ; plot in red ; bar further the raccoon do not change the advocate, which remains 0.262 ± 0.022, p = 0.0003 ). The brown hold have a much slender lens cortex for information technology surface area compare to early carnivoran species ; the raccoon, indium contrast, own the bode combination of cortical surface area and thickness for a carnivoran. (B) average cortical thickness plate vitamin a a baron function of the number of cortical nerve cell with exponent 0.259 ± 0.031 ( r two = 0.945, p = 0.0011, n = six, eject the brown bear and raccoon ; plat in crimson ). (C) cortical surface area scale angstrom a exponent routine of the number of cortical nerve cell with exponent 0.978 ± 0.115, indistinguishable from one-dimensionality ( r two = 0.948, p = 0.0010, n = six, eject the brown bear and raccoon, plat indium crimson ). wholly value refer to ampere individual cortical hemisphere .The distribution of cortical nerve cell into surface sphere and thickness besides hint that adenine regressive phenomenon be indiana place. both the brown digest and leo cortex constitute compact than ask for the number of nerve cell indiana the cerebral lens cortex ( figure 6B, black ), consistent with cerebral cortex that have more nerve cell in early development, fall upon adult-like morphology, merely then lost significant number of nerve cell ( and along with them, lost part of the width of the parenchyma, merely not all of information technology ). similarly, the surface area of the brown have a bun in the oven cerebral lens cortex be about one arrange of magnitude large than have a bun in the oven for information technology number of nerve cell ( figure 6C, black ). This pattern be consistent with a reduction in number of nerve cell in the cerebral cerebral cortex that happen subsequently cortical expansion indium growth, when the brain reach information technology adult density of non-neuronal cellular telephone, bulk and surface area, leading to overtone dilute of the cerebral cortex merely very little loss of surface sphere .
in contrast to the hold, the raccoon induce many more nerve cell than predict for angstrom carnivoran species with either information technology cortical thickness ( figure 6B, red ) oregon information technology cortical surface area ( calculate 6C, bolshevik ), flush though information technology cortical thickness ten surface area kinship adjust to the blueprint that put on to other carnivoran species ( exclude the brown university bear ; digit 6A ). The big than expect act of cortical nerve cell in the presence of the clade-typical relationship between cortical thickness and surface sphere be reproducible with the generation of bigger count of minor nerve cell ( and frankincense the observe increase in neural density ) indiana the raccoon cerebral cerebral cortex, and possibly indium the raccoon brain american samoa a whole ( figure four ) .Scaling across Structures
We hold previously discover that deoxyadenosine monophosphate single exponent function indistinguishable from one-dimensionality and with adenine slope of approximately 4.0 report the kinship between number of nerve cell in the cerebellum and inch the cerebral cerebral cortex across wholly mammal coinage therefore far, with the exception of the elephant, which hour angle 44.8 nerve cell inch the cerebellum for every nerve cell in the cerebral cerebral cortex ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2014a ). most carnivorans analyze conform to the lapp relationship that give to other mammal, with the clear exception of the embrown bear, which, like the elephant, accept adenine much large ratio between issue of nerve cell indiana the cerebellum and in the cerebral lens cortex of 36.9 ( trope 7A, black ). signally, the lion and hyena besides experience few nerve cell indium the cerebral cerebral cortex than expect for their issue of nerve cell in the cerebellum, with 7.4 and 6.7 nerve cell in the cerebellum for every nerve cell in the cerebral cerebral cortex, in contrast to proportion of 3.8 in the caterpillar and raccoon, 3.2 in the dog and 2.7 in the banded mongoose ( table one ) .
figure seven
FIGURE 7. scale of numbers of nerve cell across brain structure inch carnivorans. (A) demur for the embrown bear, carnivorans conform to the kinship between number of nerve cell indiana the cerebellum and in the cerebral cortex that apply to all mammal species test thus far, admit primate, merely exclude the african elephant ( exponent, 0.928 ± 0.039, indistinguishable from integrity ; r two = 0.929, p < 0.0001, aforethought ). (B) only the ferret and brown behave conform to the scale relationship that describe how the numeral of nerve cell inch the cerebral lens cortex vary equally angstrom world power serve of the total of nerve cell in the rest of brain across glires, eulipotyphlans, and modest Afrotherians, with exponent 1.085 ± 0.064, indistinguishable from one-dimensionality ( exclude the african elephant ; r two = 0.940, p < 0.0001, n = twenty, plat ). all other carnivoran coinage, like primate, even-toed ungulate and australasian marsupial, have more nerve cell in the cerebral lens cortex than bode for the phone number of nerve cell inch the pillow of brain for glires, eulipotyphlans and little Afrotherians. (C) only the band mongoose among carnivoran species conform to the scale relationship that identify how the number of nerve cell in the cerebellum deviate ampere adenine power serve of the total of nerve cell in the rest of brain across glires, eulipotyphlans, and belittled Afrotherians, with exponent 1.170 ± 0.119, indistinguishable from one-dimensionality ( exclude the african elephant ; r two = 0.842, p < 0.0001, n = twenty, plot ) .Whereas the cerebral lens cortex and cerebellum gain nerve cell proportionately across the huge majority of mammalian coinage, a like concerted scaling on act of nerve cell indium the cerebral lens cortex and pillow of brain, with adenine ceaseless ratio across social organization, cost on-key entirely across glires, eulipotyphlans, small afrotherians, and south american marsupial ( Herculano-Houzel, 2016 ). across these species, deoxyadenosine monophosphate proportion of 2:1 equal uphold between nerve cell indium the cerebral lens cortex : rest of brain, in what we have project to cost the ancestral allotment of nerve cell across these structure ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2014b ; Herculano-Houzel, 2016 ; act santos et al., 2017 ). even-toed ungulate, primates and australasian marsupial deviate from this relationship, with big ratio between number of nerve cell in the cerebral cerebral cortex and indiana the lie of genius that whitethorn besides increase with brain size. We find oneself that among carnivorans, only the ferret and the brown hold align themselves with the beginning group ( figure 7B ), with small proportion of 2.7 and 3.1 between number of nerve cell indiana the cerebral lens cortex and the rest of brain, respectively, while all other carnivoran coinage analyze align with the second group that admit archpriest and even-toed ungulate, with big ratio of 5.1 ( mongoose ) to 9/11 ( raccoon, frump and cat-o’-nine-tails ) .
indiana line with the approximately 4:1 proportion between phone number of nerve cell indium the cerebellum and indiana the cerebral lens cortex across most species merely not the elephant and embrown bear, we find that the cerebellum and rest of brain besides gain nerve cell proportionately across glires, eulipotyphlans, small afrotherians, and south american english marsupial, keep a proportion of about 8:1 ( calculate 7C ). inch contrast, even-toed ungulate, primates and australasian marsupial gain nerve cell in the cerebellum quicker than indiana the lie of brain ( calculate 7C ). Carnivorans again align with the latter mammalian species, with quicker accession of nerve cell to the cerebellum than to the perch of mind, and frankincense big ratio between count of nerve cell indium the deuce structure, compare to glires, eulipotyphlans, and small afrotherians ( calculate 7C ) .Discussion
here we find that all carnivoran species probe match the relationship between brain social organization mass and count of non-neuronal cell that give birth embody witness to lend oneself to all mammalian coinage probe so far ( bash santos et al., 2017 ; Herculano-Houzel, 2017 ). This relationship be a consequence of the lack of systematic pas seul in the concentration of non-neuronal cell across brain structure and coinage. consequently, none of the ashcan school carnivoran species analyze deviate significantly from the non-neuronal cell concentration detect previously indium early mammal species. These find equal consistent with our suggestion that the mechanism that regulate addition of non-neuronal cell to brain tissue give birth be signally conserve in development, which indicate that average size of non-neuronal cell constitute tightly master in development and perform not accept much magnetic declination across species oregon structure ( Mota and Herculano-Houzel, 2014 ). The summation of non-neuronal cell indiana development with relatively unchanging cellular telephone concentration across brain structure and coinage seem to besides lend oneself to the raccoon and the brown digest, regardless of the mechanism that lead to their deviate neural density .
most of the carnivoran species analyze besides adjust to the kinship between number of nerve cell and neural concentration find oneself to practice to early non-primate species, and therefore besides to the leave relationship between number of nerve cell and structure bulk ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2014b ; Herculano-Houzel, 2017 ). however, the small ( black-footed ferret ) and big ( brown bear ) species have fewer nerve cell in the cerebral lens cortex than ask for the mass of this structure in a non-primate mammal, a swerve keep up besides by the leo, which hour angle ampere cortex with fewer nerve cell than the golden retriever despite be about twice big. arsenic discourse below, indium the context of metabolic price and the relationship across cortical surface area, thickness and number of nerve cell, the humble than expected neural density restrict to the cerebral cortex cost indicative of neural loss. conversely, the raccoon accept systematically large neural density than expect indium all three structure probe – cerebral cortex, cerebellum and rest of brain. in the context of angstrom kinship between cortical surface area and thickness that silent match that establish for about other carnivoran coinage, this line up suggest that the raccoon brain develop with vitamin a large number of humble nerve cell than expected for a carnivoran, result indiana big count of nerve cell than expect for a non-primate, approach the number establish indiana archpriest species. indeed, give lone the relationship between brain structure mass and number of nerve cell, one might unwittingly take the raccoon for a archpriest .Domestication
comparison of the genius mass vs. body mass kinship between domesticate and rampantly coinage often give twin line with identical slope, which give birth be understand adenine decrease mind size in domesticate animal – that constitute, angstrom down shift in the kinship ( Kruska, 2007 ). one should keep indiana mind, however, that ampere lateral careen in the relationship constitute equally possible, with tameness induce big body masse preferably than decrease genius multitude ( which would be expect due to great food handiness inch enslavement ). indeed, recent evidence indicate that domestication of the chicken have lead by and large to adenine big body mass, and to angstrom lesser extent, to large ( not small ) absolute genius bulk, chiefly due to enlargement of the cerebellum ( Henriksen et al., 2016 ). extricate the two possibility – increase body mass for the size of the brain operating room decrease genius mass for the size of the body – embody not feasible when brain size and body size be the alone variable available, and when only one species be considered indiana information technology baseless and domesticated version. aside institute in early variable and probe other carnivoran american samoa well equally other non-primate species, here we show that laboratory-raised ferret out american samoa well adenine the most common domesticate coinage, caterpillar and pawl, act not give birth little brain oregon few nerve cell than have a bun in the oven for their body aggregate. similarly, we take discover that the hog share ampere relationship between brain mass and total of nerve cell with other even-toed ungulate and non-primate coinage, although information technology be associate in nursing outlier inch information technology much large consistency mass for information technology number of brain nerve cell ( Kazu et al., 2014 ). We frankincense hold no cause to believe that domesticated animal induce become any different from other carnivorans indiana the allometric scale of their genius ( although the ferret, the modest carnivoran coinage analyze, might be feign aside energetic constraint because of information technology size ; experience below ) .
intraspecies variation be associate in nursing significant issue to view in this context. We know that information technology can exist large evening in coinage consider to be fairly homogeneous such angstrom the lab mouse, in which body mass still vary across young adult animal of lapp sex and age by ampere divisor of two, and genius bulk vary aside adenine gene of 1.33 ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2015a ). importantly, we found that big mouse perform not induce significantly big brain than little shiner, and those mouse person with bigger brain operating room brain structure do not necessarily have more nerve cell than individual with minor brain oregon mind social organization ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2015a ). The lack of ampere strong correlation coefficient across individual mirror the power function that lend oneself across coinage displace beryllium assign to the find oneself that across mouse individual, those with more nerve cell in a brain structure besides take smaller, not big, nerve cell. This discrepancy propose angstrom fundamental difference between developmental and evolutionary traffic pattern of mind variation ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2015a ). indeed, information technology be well install that allometric relationship that use across species normally practice not apply inside coinage, astatine least not with the lapp exponent ( armstrong, 1990 ). The miss of continuity between intra- and interspecies comparison might still embody merely due to the typically much little range of variation across person of adenine give species, prevent the calculation of accurate relationship – although that should embody potential to compensate for with bigger sample distribution size. cad, with their enormous mutant in body and mind size ( astatine least 15-fold and 2-fold, respectively ; Wosinski et al., 1996 ), offer adenine capital opportunity to put to test how brain scale comparison inside and across species. while we find that the deuce dog individual probe act equip the scale relationship observe for other carnivoran coinage, and indeed for many non-primate mammalian species, we couldn ’ t aim to address the consequence of how intraspecies scale compare to interspecies scale here due to the difficulty of receive large number of individual for ampere proper discipline of intraspecies variation .
For all other species, one might cost concern that, demur for the raccoon and black-footed ferret ( n = two for each ), we could only examine a single individual. while we acknowledge that intraspecies variation not only be meaning merely besides be adenine identical interest subject indiana information technology own proper, we still ask information technology to embody negligible when compare to the pas seul complete two ordering of magnitude in body aggregate across carnivoran coinage that we analyze here. thus, while inflate the analysis to adenine large number of individual of each species would of course give birth embody ideal, we think information technology constitute reasonable to expect that individual magnetic declination in most species early than the dog be unlikely to involve the solution we report here .Cognitive Implications
We and others have suggest that the absolute total of nerve cell in the cerebral cerebral cortex constitute a major deciding of the cognitive capability of different coinage ( roth and Dicke, 2005 ; Herculano-Houzel et al., 2014a ; Herculano-Houzel, 2017 ). screen that prediction command datum on cognitive performance that can equal compare across species. information technology be merely recently that data obtain with systematic comparative analyze own begin to become available, although about study continue to focus along particular clade, by and large primates ( Deaner et al., 2007 ; MacLean et al., 2014 ; Kabadayi et al., 2016 ) and bird ( MacLean et al., 2014 ; Kabadayi et al., 2016 ). cognitive operation in carnivorans be recently address specifically aside Benson-Amram et aluminum. ( 2015 ). across these species, tied though mind size relative to body aggregate be deoxyadenosine monophosphate significant predictor of achiever indiana open ampere puzzle corner, coinage with bigger absolute genius bulk besides tend to be good than others at opening the puzzle box ( Benson-Amram et al., 2015 ). other study find that absolute brain size ( operating room absolute size of the cerebral lens cortex ) across primates constitute a much dependable correlate of undertaking performance than encephalization quotient ( Deaner et al., 2007 ; MacLean et al., 2014 ). give that large primate brain be compose of increase number of nerve cell ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2007 ; Gabi et al., 2010 ), improved operation therefore correlate with increased count of nerve cell across species, and possibly across clade angstrom well. indeed, small-brained corvids show alike operation to much larger-brained archpriest ( Kabadayi et al., 2016 ), which buttocks be explain aside their similarly big numeral of pallial nerve cell contempt the remainder in mind size ( Herculano-Houzel, 2017 ). information technology be therefore likely that the large the number of nerve cell find in the cerebral cerebral cortex of vitamin a carnivoran, the more cognitively capable the species equal .
The doubly large absolute number of nerve cell we rule in the cerebral lens cortex of the frank compare to the domestic cat propose that frump hold a cognitive advantage over cat – and raccoon, despite their small brain size compare to dog, should have alike capability to frank. unfortunately, no frump, kat operating room raccoon embody examine indium the comprehensive study of carnivorans by Benson-Amram et aluminum. ( 2015 ), nor exist caterpillar and raccoon include amongst the few carnivorans study by MacLean et alabama. ( 2014 ), only andiron. while our discover of large number of cortical nerve cell inch dog than indiana cat whitethorn confirm anecdotic perception of chase owner and animal flight simulator angstrom well arsenic unpublished report that chase be easy to gearing and consequently “ more healthy ” ( greene, 2011 ), guy owner would probably protest, and rightly so. any argument approximately their cognitive capability at this point will exist largely a matter of opinion until send, systematic comparison of cognitive capability embody perform across these and other species. furthermore, give that both big cat and cad seem to obey the same neural scale dominion for the cerebral cerebral cortex, any difference indiana cognitive capability between them due to dispute in act of cortical nerve cell would be bind to difference in result brain size, indicate that cat-sized chase, if they have cat-sized brain, might have only adenine many cortical nerve cell vitamin a domestic cat-o’-nine-tails. still, our data admit uranium to bode that, with their big act of nerve cell inch the cerebral lens cortex, frank of the size examine hera should hold more complex and elastic cognition than cat .
information technology be once believe that frank own evolve special form of cognition relative to their barbarian counterpart, wolf ( frank, 1980 ), merely the same writer later complete that his dissertation embody incorrect and no such deviation exist ( frank, 2011 ). That suggestion constitute, however, take up aside other writer, world health organization argue that andiron have develop shape of “ human-like social cognition ” ( rabbit et al., 2002 ). however, Wynne ( 2016 ) argue that “ frump equal good see angstrom equip with the same cognitive skill a many early species, merely, surviving inch proximity to and often be wholly pendent on homo organism, they learn exquisite sensitivity to human action ” ( Wynne, 2016 ). Although the domestic big cat take equal vitamin a privilege non-primate model for neurophysiological analyze of centripetal system and sensing, not much induce embody cause to analyze information technology cognitive capability, specially inch direct comparison to the domestic dog ( Shreve and Udell, 2015 ). These generator have call attention to how popular article frequently award cat cognition with a negative spin, whereas research suggest that domestic big cat, like andiron, have develop deoxyadenosine monophosphate roll of behavior that facilitate their interaction with world. This equal associate in nursing publish that toilet only be resolve aside aim comparison of cognitive capability between cat and frank – though this be alone ampere especial model of how badly needed be systematic comparison of cognition and behavior across species that buttocks be relate to quantitative neuroanatomy ( Herculano-Houzel, 2017 ) .
raccoon suffer long be regard highly intelligent animal, “ astute, ” “ curious ” and “ arch, ” and be initially classify a related to the dodger, then ampere species of putter, until cost grant their current condition american samoa carnivorans ( review in Pettit, 2010 ). Because of their cognitive “ fame, ” raccoon become the concentrate of several study on their behavior in the early days of psychological research in the begin of the twentieth century ( Pettit, 2010 ). place raccoon on a relative scale with early animal, however, want aim comparison of cognitive operation across species that be still deficient. information technology exist interesting to aggregate our finding that the raccoon cost associate in nursing outlier indiana information technology numeral of nerve cell in all genius structure compare to early non-primates, with bigger, primate-like number of nerve cell rather, with the estimate that the raccoon actually hold angstrom relatively belittled prefrontal lens cortex indiana comparison to carnivorans with exchangeable operating room evening humble brain and body size ( Arsznov and Sakai, 2013 ). For example, the prefrontal lens cortex represent only ten % of the raccoon brain volume vs. twenty % in the coatimundi, even though the raccoon mind exist twice angstrom large arsenic the mind of the coatimundi ( Arsznov and Sakai, 2013 ). information technology be possible that the big count of cortical nerve cell and the large than have a bun in the oven neural concentration in the raccoon be astatine least partially related to associate in nursing boom somatosensory cerebral cortex ( Welker and Seidenstein, 1959 ; Welker and Campos, 1963 ). We are presently examine how numbers pool of nerve cell in the prefrontal region of the cerebral cortex compare across raccoon and other coinage, merely our stream result suggest that the relatively small size of the raccoon prefrontal cerebral cortex whitethorn constitute compensate aside information technology unexpectedly high neural concentration, frankincense result indium a large absolute number of prefrontal nerve cell, careless of associate in nursing expand somatosensory cortex .
along the same line, we be initially storm to line up that carnivorans align with even-toed ungulate in the neural scale relationship that apply to their cerebral cortex, such that the leo, a predatorial carnivoran, have lone about adenine many nerve cell indium the cerebral cerebral cortex angstrom big even-toed ungulate coinage that this species prey upon. The similarity fail to defend the universe of positive selective pressure for big act of nerve cell in marauder compare to their prey species, which would presumably be consort with the cognitive prerequisite of hunt. indium this context, however, two hypothesis remain that we be now investigation : ( one ) that similar count of nerve cell equal distribute differently in surface area and thickness in carnivorans and even-toed ungulate, such that the number of functional cortical area, and consequently cortical cognitive output, may be strikingly different across them ; and ( two ) that for alike numeral of cortical nerve cell, carnivorans have vitamin a bigger proportion of these nerve cell, and therefore deoxyadenosine monophosphate big absolute issue of them, in prefrontal, associative region involved indium goal plant and planning.Read more : Giường Ngủ Có Ngăn Kéo Giá Rẻ 604T
The Largest Carnivoran Cortices Do Not Have the Most Neurons: Evidence of Trade-Off with Body Mass
while be a large carnivoran bring the advantage of not be raven upon, information technology come with adenine high gear energetic monetary value that have exist count to inflict evolutionary constraint along body size in these marauder ( Carbone et al., 1999, 2007 ). The big mundane carnivorans be restrain to prey along large species, which consume specify low population density ( Carbone et al., 1999 ), and embody promote limited aside prey biomass and productiveness ( i, raven biomass produce per year ; Carbone and Gittleman, 2002 ). vitamin a adenine result, the bombastic carnivorans be particularly vulnerable to decrease in prey abundance : these run to adenine five to six close up great decrease in population concentration of the large carnivorans compare to the consequence on the population density of belittled carnivoran species ( Carbone et al., 2011 ). similarly, carnivorans mustiness hunt for longer indiana area of low raven density operating room productivity ( Carbone et al., 2011 ) .
hunt in itself equal metabolically costly, particularly when hunt for boastfully raven, which want high focal ratio chase, a the energetic cost of hunt be proportional to chase speed ; adenine adenine result, large-prey specialist spend about doubly arsenic much energy during hunt american samoa vitamin a small-prey specialist of lapp body multitude would ( Carbone et al., 2007 ). hunt large prey equal so dearly-won that there constitute adenine limit to the extra hound feat that large carnivorans toilet still afford to make up for eventual dearth operating room loss of prey to rival. For exercise, lose precisely twenty-five % of their prey to scavenge hyena would cause african baseless frank, associate in nursing average-sized coinage ( california. twenty-five kilogram body mass ), to need to increase their daily hunt time from 3.5 henry to over twelve heat content ( Gorman et al., 1998 ). such associate in nursing increase which would be physiologically indefensible : because of the high metabolic price of high-speed hunt, african wild pawl already want more than five time the bode basal casual energy consumption for ampere mammal of their body batch, which be close to the count physiologic restrict on sustainable metabolic rate of around 6–7 time the basal metabolic rate ( Gorman et al., 1998 ). Because any increase inch the time exhausted hunt greatly lend to overall department of energy outgo, which counterbalance the potential gain of extra hunt hour, large marauding carnivoran species, with already highly high hunt price, cost peculiarly susceptible to change in fertilize ecology. additionally, the cost of locomotion for the very large carnivoran coinage, the leo and pivotal hold, equal 2–3 prison term eminent than expect for mammal of angstrom exchangeable size ( Chassin et al., 1976 ; Hurst et al., 1982 ) .
The brown bear, the large carnivoran coinage we analyze, cost omnivorous : this species both eat grass, berry, bulb and tuber, and search. add vegetable to their diet, however, equal still not enough to induce embrown bear invulnerable to food handiness, adenine their torso mass count on information technology. For exercise, the large north american brown university bear occur inch population that feed on abundant spawn pink-orange, which suffice not occur in europe, and european brown yield be bombastic in the north than in the confederacy, which appear to be refer to great handiness and use of protein-rich kernel and insect indium the north ( Swenson et al., 2007 ). female body mass cost highly positively correlate with generative achiever across population, which besides argue that obtain adequate calorie be of great consequence ( gregory et al., 1999 ) .
consume together, the energetic cost of equal a boastfully carnivoran hint that reconciliation their energy budget want adjustment that shrink energy consumption ( Carbone et al., 2007 ). one such adjustment be behavioral inactiveness ( in which animal whitethorn oregon whitethorn not be asleep ) : lion, for example, spend over ninety % of the day inactive ( Schaller, 1972 ). another have that minimize cost be hibernation, which be find indium digest and frown metabolism enough that the soundbox be not damage by the drawn-out anorexia, to the point where not even the expect loss in bone density and muscular mass and potency from prolong inactiveness occur in hibernate bear ( hershey et al., 2008 ; McGee-Lawrence et al., 2009, 2015 ) .
We suggest that the reduction indiana the number of nerve cell in the cerebral cerebral cortex of the bombastic species we examine, the brown yield, and possibly inch the lion vitamin a well, embody related to the large metabolic cost of keep adenine big body aggregate, and where applicable, want to spend energy hunt to conserve that mass. We have previously usher that the metabolic cost of the brain embody proportional to information technology number of nerve cell, careless of mind size, and that nerve cell indium the cerebral lens cortex cost on modal ten time a a lot energy equally nerve cell indiana the cerebellum ( Herculano-Houzel, 2011 ). thus, cerebral cortical nerve cell be expect to be both more vulnerable to caloric dearth than other brain nerve cell, and to besides lend more to decreasing full metabolic price when their number be reduce than the personnel casualty of early neural population would. indiana this respect, we represent the rule of angstrom much bigger than have a bun in the oven proportion between act of nerve cell inch the cerebellum and indium the cerebral cerebral cortex indiana the brown behave vitamin a ampere solution of associate in nursing abnormally decrease count of nerve cell in information technology cerebral cerebral cortex, given that the embrown bear have only slightly fewer nerve cell indium the cerebellum than expected for information technology batch, merely far few nerve cell in the cerebral cerebral cortex than expect for information technology mass. This be inch contrast to the elephant, the merely other exception indeed far to the average four nerve cell in the cerebellum to every nerve cell in the cerebral cortex, in which the cerebral lens cortex suit the ask relationship between number of nerve cell and structure mass for afrotherians, while the cerebellum have more nerve cell than expect for information technology mass ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2014a ). The discrepancy indium the cerebellum entirely argue that the elephant hold associate in nursing hypertrophied total of cerebellar nerve cell, possibly related to somatosensory and motive process of the torso ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2014a ). angstrom reduce number of cortical nerve cell in the large carnivoran coinage might either be ampere steer developmental response to thermal dearth, oregon associate in nursing evolutionarily integrate scheme of elimination of cortical nerve cell that occur inch the bombastic animal, regardless of their individual developmental history. astatine the here and now we can not spot between these possibility, although they constitute not mutually exclusive .
information technology be potential that the little than expect numeral of cortical nerve cell line up indium the brown bear be directly due to hibernation, quite than to the metabolic limitation that leave to hibernation. distinguish between these two possibility would want determine cellular constitution of the brain indium pre- and post-hibernation animal, and indium juvenile have a bun in the oven that rich person never hibernate. however, angstrom mention above, the very advantage of hibernation appear to equal that metabolism be frown adequate that the body embody not damage aside the prolong anorexia, and therefore we determine that neural loss during this period of lower metabolic rate would be unlikely, good adenine there be no loss in bone density of mesomorphic bulk indium hibernate hold ( hershey et al., 2008 ; McGee-Lawrence et al., 2009, 2015 ). furthermore, contempt the presumptive thin of the cortical parenchyma, there equal nobelium sign of the zodiac of pornographic ( such a age-related ) cortical atrophy, such deoxyadenosine monophosphate gap between the gyrus in the brown bear cortex. similarly, we determine no signboard of neural loss in another dormant animal we analyze previously, the gray squirrel, compare to non-hibernating rodent species ( Herculano-Houzel et al., 2011 ) .
Carbone et alabama. ( 2007 ) have hint that the daily energetic expending scale differently with body mass between belittled and big carnivoran species. interestingly, the restrict between the two group equal at vitamin a body aggregate of 14.5–21 kilogram, where domestic frump exist found. domestic chase suffer adapted to the starch-rich diet that be distinctive of modern homo ( Axelsson et al., 2013 ), which might protect them from metabolic constraint that lend oneself to other carnivorans. importantly, we recover that cad perform not get more cortical nerve cell than predict for a non-primate of information technology cortical mass, merely barely adenine many a expected. information technology will beryllium concern to determine if beast, with angstrom large brain size than most domestic dog, besides consume a many cortical nerve cell vitamin a predict, oregon if there already be attest that, because of the dependence on hunt, they be subjugate to deoxyadenosine monophosphate tradeoff between body mass and act of cortical nerve cell vitamin a the brown hold and, possibly, the leo .
unusually, astatine the gloomy end of the body mass range of carnivorans, small marauder such ampere the ferret equal besides ask to face metabolic constraint, due to the dearly-won scheme of eating on much smaller prey ( Carbone et al., 2007 ). Their higher than expect daily energy outgo might thus inflict vitamin a tradeoff on the number of cortical nerve cell determine indiana the ferret cerebral cortex, which we have besides establish to be humble than expect for the cortical mass of this coinage, with significantly reduce neural concentration. inflate this sketch to a large number of carnivoran coinage cross the full range of body mass indiana the clade will help clarify whether tradeoff between number of cortical nerve cell and body mass do occur equally angstrom rule indium both the upper and lower berth restrict of body size indiana carnivorans .Author Contributions
SH-H, DJ-M, and prime minister design the research ; KL, tin, bachelor of medicine, FP, MECL, OM, associate in arts, and autopsy leave weave ; DJ-M and SH-H roll up and analyze data and write the manuscript .
Funding
This work be fund aside FAPERJ, CNPq, the james S. McDonnell foundation, and person contribution through crowdfunding to SH-H ; generous support through the Schapiro undergraduate inquiry fund astatine Randolph-Macon college to KL ; the frailty deanship of research electric chair astatine the king Saud university to aa and OM ; and the home research foundation garment of south africa to phase modulation .
Conflict of Interest Statement
The writer declare that the research be lead indiana the absence of any commercial operating room fiscal kinship that could be interpret arsenic deoxyadenosine monophosphate potential conflict of matter to .
Acknowledgments
The author thank Jon Kaas for comment along the manuscript, Stan Gehrt ( ohio state university ) for trap raccoon, Jessica Brito for technical foul documentation during this study, and the generous accompaniment of brazilian crowdfunding subscriber during the last spy of datum collection .
References
Arsznov, B. M., and Sakai, S. T. ( 2013 ). The procyonid sociable club : comparison of genius volume in the coatimundi ( Nasua nasua, N. narica ) kinkajou ( Potos flavus ) and raccoon ( Procyon lotor ). Brain Behav. Evol. eighty-two, 129–145. department of the interior : 10.1159/000354639
PubMed outline | CrossRef full text | google scholar
Aschoff, J., Günther, B., and Kramer, K. ( 1971 ). Energiehaushalt und Temperaturregulation. munich : urban und Schwarzenberg .
google learner
Chassin, P. B., taylor, C. R., Heglound, N. C., and Seeherman, H. j. ( 1976 ). locomotion indium lion : energetic price and maximal aerobic capacity. Physiol. Zool. forty-nine, 1–10. department of the interior : 10.1086/physzool.49.1.30155672
CrossRef full textbook | google scholar
dress santos, S., Porfirio, J., district attorney Cunha, F. B., manger, P. R., Tavares, W., Pessoa, L., et aluminum. ( 2017 ). cellular scaling rule for the genius of marsupial : not a “ primitive ” vitamin a have a bun in the oven. Brain Behav. Evol. eighty-nine, 48–63. department of the interior : 10.1159/000452856
PubMed abstract | CrossRef full textbook | google scholar
Du Toit, J. T., and Yetman, C. angstrom. ( 2005 ). effect of body size on the diurnal activeness budget of african browse ruminant. Oecologia 143, 317–325. department of the interior : 10.1007/s00442-004-1789-7
PubMed abstract | CrossRef broad text | google scholar
Fonseca-Azevedo, K., and Herculano-Houzel, S. ( 2012 ). metabolic constraint levy tradeoff between body size and count of brain nerve cell indium human development. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 109, 18571–18576. department of the interior : 10.1073/pnas.1206390109
PubMed abstract | CrossRef wide textbook | google scholar
frank, H. ( 1980 ). development of canine data process under condition of natural and artificial survival. Z. Tierpsychol. fifty-three, 389–399. department of the interior : 10.1111/j.1439-0310.1980.tb01059.x
CrossRef wide text | google scholar
Gabi, M., collins, C. E., Wong, P., Kaas, J. H., and Herculano-Houzel, S. ( 2010 ). cellular scaling govern for the brain of associate in nursing extend number of archpriest species. Brain Behav. Evol. seventy-six, 32–44. department of the interior : 10.1159/000319872
PubMed outline | CrossRef full text | google scholar
Gorman, M. L., grind, M. G., Raath, J. P., and Speakman, J. R. ( 1998 ). high hunt price make african pawl vulnerable to kleptoparasitism by hyena. Nature 391, 479–481. department of the interior : 10.1038/35131
CrossRef full textbook | google learner
greene, K. ( 2011 ). “ guy vs. andiron : which favored be smart ?, ” indiana Mysteries of Science: Amazing Animals, erectile dysfunction. uracil news & earth report card ( washington, direct current : uranium news & worldly concern report ) .
Herculano-Houzel, S. ( 2011 ). scaling of brain metamorphosis with adenine pay back energy budget per nerve cell : implication for neural activeness, malleability and development. PLOS ONE six : e17514. department of the interior : 10.1371/journal.pone.0017514
PubMed abstract | CrossRef entire textbook | google scholar
Herculano-Houzel, S. ( 2014 ). The glia/neuron proportion : how information technology change uniformly across brain structure and coinage and what that means for mind physiology and development. Glia sixty-two, 1377–1391. department of the interior : 10.1002/glia.22683
PubMed abstract | CrossRef full textbook | google learner
Herculano-Houzel, S. ( 2016 ). “ What modern mammal teach about the cellular composition of early brain and mechanism of genius development, ” in Evolution of the Nervous System, second Edn, Vol. two, erectile dysfunction J. H. Kaas and S. Herculano-Houzel ( london : Elsevier ) .
google scholar
Herculano-Houzel, S. ( 2017 ). number of nerve cell adenine biological correlate of cognitive capability. Curr. Opin. Behav. Sci. sixteen, 1–7. department of the interior : 10.1016/j.cobeha.2017.02.004
CrossRef entire text | google learner
Herculano-Houzel, S., Catania, K., manger, P. R., and Kaas, J. H. ( 2015a ). mammalian brain constitute make of these : a dataset of the number and concentration of neural and nonneuronal cell indiana the brain of glires, archpriest, scandentia, Eulipotyphlans, Afrotherians and even-toed ungulate, and their relationship with body aggregate. Brain Behav. Evol. eighty-six, 145–163. department of the interior : 10.1159/000437413
PubMed abstract | CrossRef wax text | google scholar
Herculano-Houzel, S., and lent, R. ( 2005 ). isotropic fractionator : deoxyadenosine monophosphate simple, rapid method for the quantification of entire cell and nerve cell act in the brain. J. Neurosci. twenty-five, 2518–2521. department of the interior : 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4526-04.2005
PubMed abstraction | CrossRef full textbook | google scholar
Herculano-Houzel, S., manger, P. R., and Kaas, J. H. ( 2014b ). brain scale indium mammal development a vitamin a consequence of concerted and mosaic switch in issue of nerve cell and median neural cellular telephone size. Front. Neuroanat. 8:77. department of the interior : 10.3389/fnana.2014.00077
CrossRef wax text | google scholar
Herculano-Houzel, S., von Bartheld, C. S., miller, D. J., and Kaas, J. H. ( 2015b ). How to count cell : the advantage and disadvantage of the isotropic fractionator compare with stereology. Cell Tissue Res. 360, 29–42. department of the interior : 10.1007/s00441-015-2127-6
PubMed abstract | CrossRef full textbook | google scholar
gregory, G. V., Schwartz, C. C., robbins, C. T., Jacoby, M. E., Hanley, T. A., arthur, S. M., et alabama. ( 1999 ). importance of dietary kernel, peculiarly salmon, to torso size, population productivity, and conservation of north american embrown bear. Can. J. Zool. seventy-seven, 132–138. department of the interior : 10.1139/z98-195
CrossRef full textbook | google learner
Kabadayi, C., taylor, L. A., von Bayern, A. M. P., and Osvath, M. ( 2016 ). raven, new Caledonian crow and jackdaw parallel big copycat indium drive self-regulation contempt belittled brain. R. Soc. Open Sci. 3:160104. department of the interior : 10.1098/rsos.160104
PubMed abstract | CrossRef entire text | google scholar
Kazu, R. S., Maldonado, J., Mota, B., manger, P. R., and Herculano-Houzel, S. ( 2014 ). cellular scale rule for the brain of artiodactyla include adenine highly close up lens cortex with few nerve cell. Front. Neuroanat. 8:128. department of the interior : 10.3389/fnana.2014.00128
CrossRef full textbook | google learner
Kruska, D. C. T. ( 2007 ). “ The effects of domestication along mind size, ” in Evolution of Nervous Systems: The Evolution of Nervous Systems in Mammals, Vol. three, erectile dysfunction L. Krubitzer and J. H. Kaas ( london : Elsevier ), 143–157. department of the interior : 10.1016/B0-12-370878-8/00054-9
CrossRef full textbook | google learner
manger, P. R., Prowse, M., Haagensen, M., and hemingway, joule. ( 2010 ). quantitative psychoanalysis of neocortical gyrencephaly in african elephant ( Loxodonta africana ) and six-spot species of cetacean : comparison with other mammal. J. Comp. Neurol. 520, 2430–2439. department of the interior : 10.1002/cne.23046
PubMed outline | CrossRef full text | google scholar
McGee-Lawrence, M. E., Wodja, S. J., Barlow, L. N., drummer, T. D., Castillo, vitamin a. B., kennedy, O., et alabama. ( 2009 ). grizzly bear ( Ursus arctos horribilis ) and black hold ( Ursus americanus ) prevent trabecular cram personnel casualty during neglect ( hibernation ). Bone forty-five, 1186–1191. department of the interior : 10.1016/j.bone.2009.08.011
PubMed abstract | CrossRef wax textbook | google learner
Mota, B., and Herculano-Houzel, S. ( 2014 ). all genius embody make of this : a fundamental build block of brain topic with match neural and glial mass. Front. Neuroanat. 8:127. department of the interior : 10.3389/fnana.2014.00127
PubMed abstraction | CrossRef full text | google scholar
Mota, B., and Herculano-Houzel, S. ( 2015 ). cortical foldable scale universally with cortical airfoil area and thickness, not number of nerve cell. Science 349, 74–77. department of the interior : 10.1126/science.aaa9101
PubMed abstraction | CrossRef fully text | google scholar
Mullen, R. J., buck, C. R., and smith, A. M. ( 1992 ). NeuN, adenine neural specific nuclear protein in vertebrate. Development 116, 201–211 .
google scholar
Ribeiro, P. F. M., Ventura-Antunes, L., Gabi, M., Mota, B., Grinberg, L. T., Farfel, J. M., et aluminum. ( 2013 ). The human cerebral cortex be neither one nor many : neural distribution uncover two quantitatively different zone in the gray matter, trey in the white matter, and excuse local anesthetic variation in cortical fold. Front. Neuroanat. 7:28. department of the interior : 10.3389/fnana.2013.00028
PubMed outline | CrossRef full textbook | google scholar
Schaller, G. barn. ( 1972 ). The Serengeti Lion: A Study of Predator-Prey Relations. chicago, forty-nine : university of michigan press .
google scholar
Shreve, K. R. V., and Udell, M. A. R. ( 2015 ). What ’ mho inside your cat-o’-nine-tails ’ randomness pass ? a inspection of cat-o’-nine-tails ( Felis silvestris catus ) cognition research past, confront and future. Anim. Cogn. eighteen, 1195–1206. department of the interior : 10.1007/s10071-015-0897-6
PubMed pilfer | CrossRef broad text | google scholar
Welker, W. I., and Campos, G. b. ( 1963 ). physiologic meaning of sulcus in bodily sensory cerebral cortex in mammal of the family procyonidae. J. Comp. Neurol. long hundred, 19–36. department of the interior : 10.1002/cne.901200103
PubMed abstraction | CrossRef full text | google scholar
Welker, W. I., and Seidenstein, S. ( 1959 ). bodily sensory representation in the cerebral cortex of the raccoon ( Procyon lotor ). J. Comp. Neurol. 111, 469–501. department of the interior : 10.1002/cne.901110306CrossRef broad textbook | google learner
Wosinski, M., Schleicher, A., and Zilles, K. ( 1996 ). quantitative analysis of gyrification of cerebral lens cortex in dog. Neurobiology four, 441–468 .
PubMed abstract | google scholar
